SCOTUS Seems Ready To Uphold A State Law That Bars Abortion After 15 Weeks, But It’s Less Clear If There Will Be A Majority To End The Right To Abortion Nationwide

SCOTUS Seems Ready To Uphold A State Law That Bars Abortion After 15 Weeks, But It’s Less Clear If There Will Be A Majority To End The Right To Abortion Nationwide

- in Politics

34 min ago”This is the long game exemplified,” says Dana Bash on the conservative legal strategy on abortion ban cases From CNN’s Dana Bash / Written by CNN’s Maureen Chowdhury

The arguments presented by the Mississippi solicitor general and the questioning by the recently appointed conservative Supreme Court justices are an example of a “very strategic legal strategy and political strategy that has been in the work for decades,” said CNN’s Dana Bash.

“This is the long game exemplified. Because conservatives have been pushing, pushing, pushing to pack the courts on the lower levels and, of course, ultimately the Supreme Court,” Bash said. She added that many conservatives continue to support former President Donald Trump because of his appointments to the Supreme Court.

“If you want to know politically why so many conservatives to this day stick by Donald Trump, it’s because of what we heard in the court today, the questioning by his three nominees were exactly what they were going for. We don’t know how they’re going to decide. But certainly they left some very big bread crumbs as to where they’re headed,” Bash explained.

30 min agoThe oral arguments have ended. Here’s what happens next. From CNN’s Dan Berman

(Erin Schaff/Pool/AFP/Getty Images)The oral arguments have concluded, and the Supreme Court will now take the case under consideration.

This week, the nine will sit alone in a conference room and go over the case.

They’ll go in order, with Chief Justice John Roberts explaining his vote and reasoning, then following by seniority: Clarence Thomas (conservative), Stephen Breyer (the senior liberal), Samuel Alito (conservative), Sonia Sotomayor (liberal), Elena Kagan (liberal), Neil Gorsuch (conservative), Brett Kavanaugh (conservative) and Amy Coney Barrett (conservative).

All justices have publicly described this process as orderly and collegial.

Remember, their views are often known going in and what’s going to matter is the language in the final opinion. The senior justice in the majority and minority will get to choose who writes the opinion, a process that will take months, with plenty of drafts going back and forth between chambers, and rarely, a vote change.

Most famously, Roberts changed his vote to uphold Obamacare in 2012, after initially deciding to kill it.

28 min agoBarrett asks about availability of adoption as arguments come to a closeFrom CNN’s Tierney Sneed

(Sarah Silbiger/Pool/Getty Images)Justice Amy Coney Barrett returned to a theme she has asked repeatedly about during today’s hearing, asking how the growing availability of adoption — via so-called “safe haven” laws — changes the reliance interest.

US Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar said that there is “nothing new.” Her question wraps up Prelogar’s argument period and Mississippi Solicitor General Scott Stewart, when stepped up for a brief rebuttal, seized on Barrett’s question.

He said the rise of “safe haven” laws relieve a “huge burden.”

Stewart finished his rebuttal without any additional questions from the court.

The hearing ended after the rebuttal, having lasted just under two hours.

1 hr 8 min agoUS solicitor general urges justices to uphold precedentFrom CNN’s Dan Berman

US Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar, the Biden administration’s top lawyer before the Supreme Court, is arguing against the court disrupting Roe v. Wade, saying people have relied on the right to an abortion for nearly 50 years.

“Nearly half of the states already have or are expected to enact bans on abortion at all stages of pregnancy, many without exceptions for rape or incest. Women who are unable to travel hundreds of miles to gain access to legal abortion will be required to continue with their pregnancies and give birth with profound effects on their bodies, their health, and the course of their lives,” Prelogar said. “If this court renounces the liberty interest recognized in Roe and reaffirmed in Casey, it would be an unprecedented contraction of individual rights and a stark departure from principles of stare decisis,” she continued.

“The court has never revoked a right that is so fundamental to so many Americans and so central to their ability to participate fully and equally in society,” Prelogar told the justices.

1 hr 11 min agoThe future of Roe v. Wade will be defined by Roberts and KavanaughAnalysis from CNN’s Dan Berman

Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett have asked relative softballs of Mississippi Solicitor General Scott Stewart and been tough on Julie Rikelman, a lawyer representing Jackson Women’s Health Organization.

Barrett asked about “safe haven laws,” and women’s ability to give up children for adoption.

Thomas, who has lobbied to

Source Title:
SCOTUS seems ready to uphold a state law that bars abortion after 15 weeks, but it’s less clear if there will be a majority to end the right to abortion nationwide

Go To The SourceRead More

Leave a Reply

You may also like

Our Favorite Product Releases This Week: Lunya, Away, Allbirds And More

There are a ton of great products that